Re: Quick Reply
Reply #1 –
I agree with either on or off option, I never understood why have it expandable, that made no sense to me. I prefer to always have it and the text editor and smileys there as well.
In that is the case, don't even have a posting page just have everything in the QR. Makes for much neater and faster posting and no need for another page to load.
Re: Quick Reply
Reply #4 –
I'll make the PR to get us on our way and indeed I think there is more that can be done to consolidate those two areas !
Re: Quick Reply
Reply #5 –
Why the rush to eliminate the post page? I bet lots of people like it. If you structure the code underneath carefully the overhead of having the option of QR or post page is very small.
The post page can help people by having less distraction, especially when previewing a post. And it has a set number of replies below it to pull into via the quote button. With QR the number available depends on the pagination of the forum.
I think on/off with expand/collapse matching the last user state is a great idea though. As has been said it's more like how the rest of the forum operates.