Re: Likes Layout
Reply #1 –
The first one is probably better, as you really don't have a Dislike button. Simply un-Liking a post does not imply that the post is Disliked. The second version of Un-Like seems to look more like Dislike, rather than a removal of the Like.
Re: Likes Layout
Reply #2 –
I agree, the first one seems to fit better.
Re: Likes Layout
Reply #3 –
+1. I had in mind as a suggestion. Current like button looks a bit odd. But was not sure how people will receive it and hence kept quiet. Nice suggestion, first one will be better. But I guess if we can go a bit unconventional and find something different, it will be nice.
Re: Likes Layout
Reply #4 –
I like stars as well (probably coming from github UI), but if the idea is to change, then probably what ET said makes sense.
Re: Likes Layout
Reply #9 –
Keep it is nice I think, though you are right: show 0 most of the times is a waste, maybe shown it only when there is something to see.
Also I would drop the "post" from the button label.
Re: Likes Layout
Reply #11 –
They look great, nice job
Re: Likes Layout
Reply #12 –
Okay, honestly, it's a bit confusing right now. The Like post button has a thumbs up and a green icon, so it almost seems like every post is liked by default.
Why not a blank (or unsaturated) thumb for default, and colored/green + when liked? That way it doesn't look like I've Liked (god that's an awkward sentence) every post so far.